PreQualifySubs.com Contact sales
Guides / Insurance

Waiver of subrogation in construction

A waiver of subrogation means an insurer gives up its right to recover a claim payment from another party, usually the GC or owner. Subcontracts often require one on general liability, workers' comp and auto. A mark on a certificate is not enough. The policy needs an endorsement that allows the waiver.

This guide explains how these forms usually work. Your policy and your contract wording control, and state law varies. It is not legal or insurance advice.

What subrogation is

Subrogation is an insurer's right to step into its customer's shoes after it pays a claim. If someone else caused the loss, the insurer can go after that party to get its money back.

Policies spell this out. In ISO's standard general liability form, CG 00 01, the condition is called Transfer Of Rights Of Recovery Against Others To Us. Once the insurer pays, the insured's rights to recover from others pass to the insurer. The insured must do nothing after a loss to impair those rights. Workers' comp policies carry the same kind of right. NCCI's waiver form opens by stating that the insurer may recover its payments from anyone liable for an injury the policy covers.

In most cases subrogation is fair. It puts the cost of a loss on the party that caused it. On a construction site, though, that party is often a company you work with every day.

What a waiver of subrogation does

A waiver of subrogation is an agreement that the insurer will not try to recover from a named party, or a group of parties. That holds even if the party helped cause the loss. Two things have to line up for it to work:

The contract alone is not enough if the policy does not allow the waiver. The endorsement alone is not enough either. Most waiver endorsements apply only where a written contract requires them.

The base general liability form does not forbid a waiver signed before a loss. Its condition only bars the insured from impairing recovery rights after the loss. Contracts still ask for an endorsement, because it puts the waiver on the policy in writing and removes the argument.

A fictional example

Uinta Roofing Co. is the roofing sub to Granite Peak Builders on a medical office building. A Uinta roofer steps on a floor opening that another trade left uncovered and is hurt. Uinta's workers' comp insurer pays $48,000 in medical bills and lost wages.

The insurer believes Granite Peak's site supervision played a part. Without a waiver, it could sue Granite Peak to recover some or all of the $48,000. Granite Peak would hand that suit to its own general liability insurer. Two insurers would then fight over a loss between two companies that want to keep working together.

Now assume the subcontract required a workers' comp waiver in favor of Granite Peak, and Uinta's policy carries the endorsement. Uinta's insurer has given up its right to sue Granite Peak for that payment. The fight does not happen.

The waiver limits the insurer. It does not limit the injured worker. The roofer may still be able to sue Granite Peak directly, depending on state law. What a waiver does to the insurer's lien on the worker's own recovery also varies by state.

Why GCs and owners require it

Construction contracts pass insurance requirements down the chain. The owner asks the GC for waivers. The GC passes the same requirement to each sub. The reasons are practical.

Waivers are not free for the sub, and they are often misunderstood. A law firm that handles workers' comp subrogation points out that a workers' comp waiver does not stop an injured employee from suing the contractor. It also notes that the sub loses a recovery that would have reduced the claim cost behind its experience mod. See the EMR guide for how claims feed into the mod.

The endorsements, line by line

Each policy needs its own waiver. A waiver on general liability does nothing for workers' comp, and the reverse is also true.

PolicyCommon formWhat to check
General liabilityISO CG 24 04, Waiver of Transfer of Rights of Recovery Against Others to Us. Editions 05 09 and 12 19 are both in use. Carriers may use their own version.The schedule names the GC and owner, or says the waiver applies when a written contract requires it.
Workers' compNCCI WC 00 03 13, Waiver of Our Right to Recover From Others Endorsement (Ed. 4-84). Some states use their own form.The schedule names the party or describes a blanket waiver. The state's form is used where required.
Business autoISO CA 04 44 for named parties, or CA 04 43, which applies when a written contract requires a waiver.The waiver is on the auto policy itself, not only on general liability.

General liability: CG 24 04 or the carrier's equivalent

ISO's general liability waiver is CG 24 04. It adds to the transfer of rights condition in the CGL policy. Two editions are common, and they are worded differently.

Carriers may write their own waiver forms. Read the wording, not just the title. Check whether it covers completed operations, and whether it depends on a written contract signed before the loss.

Workers' comp: WC 00 03 13

The standard workers' comp waiver is NCCI's WC 00 03 13, the Waiver of Our Right to Recover From Others Endorsement. Copies in use carry the edition date 4-84. The insurer agrees not to enforce its right of recovery against the person or organization named in the schedule. Copies often include a sentence that limits the waiver to work done under a written contract that requires it. The form also says it does not benefit anyone who is not named in the schedule.

Some states use their own forms. California's version is WC 04 03 06. Texas uses WC 42 03 04 A, which has boxes for a specific waiver or a blanket waiver and a line for the premium charge.

Business auto

ISO's business auto program has its own waiver endorsements. CA 04 44 applies to the persons or organizations named in its schedule. CA 04 43 applies automatically when a written contract requires a waiver. If your contract requires a waiver on auto, look for it on the auto policy.

Property and builder's risk

Property waivers work the same way in a different policy. Under AIA A201-2017, Section 11.3, the owner and contractor waive rights against each other for damage covered by property insurance, and that waiver reaches subcontractors. The property and builder's risk policies must allow it. That is part of the owner's and GC's property program, not the sub's liability certificate.

Blanket versus scheduled waivers

A scheduled waiver, also called a specific waiver, names each party. A blanket waiver applies to anyone the insured agreed in a written contract to give a waiver to.

ScheduledBlanket
How it names partiesLists each GC, owner or other party by nameRefers to parties the insured agreed in writing to give a waiver to
Works well forA sub with a few large contractsA sub with many GCs and jobs
Common failureA party is left off, or the name does not match the contractNo written contract, or the contract was signed after the loss
What the GC checksIts exact legal name, and the owner's, are in the scheduleThe subcontract requires the waiver in writing before work starts

Blanket wording shows up in real policies. A common blanket schedule on CG 24 04 names any party "as required by written contract" signed before the loss. The Texas comp form has a blanket box for any person or organization the insured agreed by written contract to give the waiver to.

A blanket waiver only helps a GC if the subcontract requires the waiver in writing. Get the subcontract signed before the sub starts work. A verbal promise or an unsigned purchase order is a weak foundation.

States that restrict waivers on workers' comp

Most states allow workers' comp waivers. A few restrict them, mostly in construction. The rules below are ones we confirmed in the statute text. This is not a complete list, and laws change. Check the law where the project is.

StateRuleStatute
KentuckyIt is against public policy and unlawful for an owner or employer to require another employer to waive its comp remedies as a condition of a contract or purchase order. An owner also may not favor a bidder that waives them voluntarily.KRS 342.700(3)
New HampshireAny agreement that requires an employer or its comp insurer to waive subrogation rights under the comp law is prohibited.RSA 281-A:13, VI
MissouriWhere one party to a contract or subcontract is an employer in the construction group, a waiver of comp subrogation for a future injury or death is void. The statute calls it against public policy.RSMo 287.150, subsection 6
KansasIn private construction contracts, a provision that waives subrogation for losses covered by liability or workers' comp insurance is void. There are exceptions for wrap-up programs, owners and contractors protective insurance, and project management protective insurance.K.S.A. 16-1803(b)(3)

Two points follow. A GC that works in these states should have its subcontract forms reviewed for each one. And the Kansas rule reaches liability insurance too, so it affects general liability waivers on private construction jobs there.

Texas and California allow comp waivers but use their own endorsement forms, as noted above.

What it costs

A waiver has a price because the insurer gives up a way to get money back. The price depends on the line of coverage, the state and the carrier.

Rates and rules change. Ask the agent for the current number before you bid.

There is also an indirect cost. When a comp insurer cannot recover from a third party, the sub loses a recovery that would have offset the claim. A sub can price these costs into its bids. A GC that requires waivers from every sub is asking each one to carry them.

How a waiver shows on a certificate

The ACORD 25 certificate has a column headed SUBR WVD, short for subrogation waived. The producer marks it on the row of each policy that has a waiver. The notice at the top of the form says that, when subrogation is waived, some policies need an endorsement. It also says a statement on the certificate does not give the certificate holder rights in place of that endorsement.

So a mark in the SUBR WVD column is a pointer, not proof. The proof is the endorsement. Ask for a copy of the waiver endorsement for each line your contract covers, with the form number and edition visible. See how to read an ACORD 25 for the rest of the form.

Put this on a prequal form you can send today

The free prequal form generator builds a branded subcontractor prequalification PDF. Add your logo, pick sections, download. It includes an insurance requirements table where you set your own minimums.

What to ask for in prequalification

Prequalification is the time to find out whether a sub can meet your waiver requirement. A gap is easier to fix before the subcontract is signed.

  1. Ask whether the sub's general liability, auto and workers' comp policies carry blanket waivers, scheduled waivers or none.
  2. Ask for sample copies of the waiver endorsements, with form numbers and editions.
  3. Ask which states the sub works in. Flag Kentucky, New Hampshire, Missouri and Kansas for review.
  4. Ask for the agent's name, phone and email so you can confirm coverage later.
  5. Ask for three years of experience mods and OSHA 300A summaries for the safety side of the file. See the EMR guide and the OSHA 300A guide.
  6. Put the requirement in the subcontract, not only on the prequal form. Waiver endorsements depend on a written contract.

Our free prequal form builder has an insurance section with a requirements table and a request for a sample certificate. Contracts usually ask for waivers together with additional insured status and primary and non-contributory wording, so review all three at once.

FAQ

What does waiver of subrogation mean in simple terms?

It means an insurer agrees not to sue another party to get back money it paid on a claim. In construction, that party is usually the GC or owner. The contract creates the promise, and an endorsement on the policy allows it.

Is a waiver of subrogation the same as additional insured status?

No. Additional insured status gives the GC coverage under the sub's policy. A waiver stops the sub's insurer from suing the GC to recover what it paid. Contracts often require both, plus primary and non-contributory wording.

Does a waiver of subrogation cost extra?

Often, yes. On workers' comp the charge is usually a percentage of premium set by state rules and the carrier. On general liability and auto, each carrier sets its own charge. Ask the agent for the current price.

What is the difference between a blanket and a specific waiver?

A specific, or scheduled, waiver names each party. A blanket waiver applies to anyone the insured agreed in a written contract to give a waiver to. A blanket waiver still needs that written contract, signed before the loss.

Can a certificate of insurance create a waiver of subrogation?

No. The ACORD 25 says a statement on the certificate does not give the holder rights in place of an endorsement. Ask for a copy of the endorsement itself.

Which states restrict waivers on workers' comp?

Kentucky and New Hampshire bar contract terms that require an employer to waive comp subrogation. Missouri voids them in contracts with construction employers. Kansas voids them in private construction contracts, with some exceptions. Other states may have rules too, so check where the project is.

Does a waiver stop an injured worker from suing the GC?

No. A workers' comp waiver limits the insurer's right to recover what it paid. The injured worker's own claim against the GC is a separate matter under state law.

What to require in your prequal

  • A yes or no for a waiver on general liability, auto and workers' comp, and whether each is blanket or scheduled.
  • Copies of the waiver endorsements, with form numbers and editions.
  • The states the sub works in, with a flag for states that restrict comp waivers.
  • The agent's contact details, so you can verify coverage.
  • A signed subcontract that requires the waiver before work starts.

Sources

We can make this easier

PreQualifySubs.com gives every GC one prequal link. Subs fill their profile once and reuse it for every GC. We check licenses, liens, OSHA records, insurance and references against the source, so you see a verified level instead of a stack of PDFs. Free for subs.