Experience modification rate (EMR)
An experience modification rate (EMR) is a workers' comp multiplier that compares your company's injury claims to what is expected for your size and trade. NCCI or your state rating bureau calculates it from three years of payroll and losses. A 1.0 is average. Below 1.0 lowers your premium. Above 1.0 raises it and can cost you bids.
What an EMR is
An experience modification rate is a multiplier your workers' comp carrier applies to your premium. NCCI calls it the experience rating modification factor. Most people say "the mod" or "e-mod." In California you will also hear X-Mod.
Premium starts with a rate for each job class, charged per $100 of payroll. Roofing has a higher rate than clerical work because it has more potential for injuries. That rate is an average for the whole class. The mod adjusts it for your own claim history.
Losses lower than expected for your size and classes earn a credit mod below 1.0. Higher losses earn a debit mod above 1.0. NCCI describes a 1.20 as a prediction that your future losses will be 20% worse than the average employer in your class.
Under NCCI's plan, experience rating is mandatory for every employer that meets the state's premium eligibility rules. The mod changes what you pay for workers' comp. It is also a number GCs and owners ask for in prequalification.
Who calculates your EMR
Your carrier does not set your mod. Carriers report payroll and claims to a rating organization, which calculates the mod. NCCI, the National Council on Compensation Insurance, does this in most states. Several states have their own bureau. NCCI's guide to experience rating sorts them like this:
| States | Who produces the mod | How it works |
|---|---|---|
| Most states | NCCI | NCCI's Experience Rating Plan applies. NCCI issues the mod. |
| Indiana, Massachusetts, North Carolina | State bureau (ICRB, WCRIBMA, NCRB) | NCCI's plan applies. The bureau rates employers that work only in that state. |
| Minnesota, New York, Wisconsin | State bureau (MWCIA, NYCIRB, WCRB) | The bureau rates in-state employers. Employers that also work in another participating state get NCCI's interstate mod. |
| California, Delaware, Michigan, New Jersey, Pennsylvania | State bureau (WCIRB, DCRB, CAOM, NJCRIB, PCRB) | NCCI's plan does not apply. The bureau issues a separate mod under its own rules. |
| North Dakota, Ohio, Washington, Wyoming | State fund | These are monopolistic states. The state fund runs its own plan and rates. |
Work in two or more states that use NCCI's plan and NCCI issues one interstate mod. Work in only one and you get an intrastate mod. Work in an NCCI state and a state like Pennsylvania and you get two separate mods.
Rating values such as the split point, weight and ballast differ by state and change every year. Treat any rating value on this page as an example unless a named source backs it.
What an EMR of 1.0 means
A mod of 1.00 is called unity. It means your losses are in line with what the plan expects for your size and classes. Experience rating does not raise or lower your premium.
The mod is a straight multiplier. NCCI's own example uses $100,000 of premium before the mod.
| Mod | Premium before mod | Premium after mod | Effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.75 | $100,000 | $75,000 | 25% credit |
| 1.00 | $100,000 | $100,000 | No change |
| 1.25 | $100,000 | $125,000 | 25% debit |
A 1.00 does not always mean average losses. NCCI also assigns 1.00 when an employer is not eligible for experience rating, does not have enough data, is a new business, or could not provide data after an ownership change. When a sub reports 1.00, ask whether it is a calculated mod or a unity mod because the company is not rated.
The experience period
The mod uses about three years of payroll and losses. It skips the most recent year. That year is left out because carriers have not reported it yet when the mod is calculated.
Under NCCI's plan, a policy is in the experience period if it started no less than 21 months and no more than 57 months before the rating effective date. Carriers do not have to report a policy's data until 18 months after the policy starts. NCCI generally calculates the mod 60 to 90 days before the rating effective date.
For an employer that renews every January 1, it works out like this.
| Rating effective date | Policy years used | Not used yet |
|---|---|---|
| January 1, 2025 | 2021, 2022, 2023 | 2024 |
| January 1, 2026 | 2022, 2023, 2024 | 2025 |
| January 1, 2027 | 2023, 2024, 2025 | 2026 |
Two things follow. A claim stays in your mod for three ratings in a row. And safety work you do this year won't show up for about two years. Short-term policies or changed policy dates can shorten or stretch the period. NCCI's guide gives a range from under 12 months to 45 months of data.
How the EMR is calculated
The calculation compares actual losses to expected losses. It splits each into two layers and weights them differently.
Expected losses
Each class code has an expected loss rate (ELR) per $100 of payroll. ELR times payroll divided by 100 gives expected losses. Each class line also has a discount ratio (D-ratio), the share of expected losses that should fall below the split point. Expected losses times the D-ratio gives expected primary losses. The rest are expected excess losses.
Actual losses
Actual losses are the incurred amounts on your claims, meaning what has been paid plus the reserve for what the carrier still expects to pay. An open claim counts at its full reserve. Indemnity and medical are combined into one number per claim.
Primary losses, excess losses and the split point
Each claim is split at a dollar amount called the split point. The part up to the split point is the primary loss. The part above it is the excess loss. A claim under the split point is all primary.
Primary losses count in full. Excess losses count only in part. NCCI's plan gives more weight to how often you have claims than to how big they are. Many small claims predict more claims. One large claim is more likely to be bad luck.
NCCI used one countrywide split point for years. Its 2022 filing listed it at $18,500. NCCI then moved to a split point for each state, set so that about 40% of expected losses are primary. The change rolled out state by state, starting with ratings tied to rate filings effective on or after November 1, 2023. Texas, for example, approved $16,500 for ratings on or after July 1, 2024. NCCI expects to update each state's split point with that state's annual loss cost or rate filing. Ask your agent for your state's current value.
Accident limits
Very large claims are capped before they enter the formula. Each state sets a per-claim accident limit. For an accident that injures two or more people, NCCI's limit is twice that. Anything above the cap is left out.
Weight and ballast
- Weight (W) is the share of excess losses that counts. It is small for small employers and grows with size, because a big employer's own record is more reliable.
- Ballast (B) is added to both the actual and expected side. It pulls the mod toward 1.00 and limits the effect of any single loss. Ballast rises as expected losses rise.
Both come from state tables keyed to your expected losses and updated with each state's annual filing. NCCI's 2022 filing recalibrated the credibility parameters behind them for the first time in over two decades.
Medical-only claims and the ERA discount
A medical-only claim pays for treatment but no lost wages. Most NCCI states have approved the Experience Rating Adjustment (ERA), which counts only 30% of a medical-only claim, both primary and excess. NCCI says ERA also reduces the incentive to pay medical-only claims without reporting them.
The formula
Mod = (Ap + W × Ae + (1 − W) × Ee + B) ÷ (E + B)
- Ap is actual primary losses. Ae is actual excess losses.
- E is total expected losses. Ee is expected excess losses, which is E minus expected primary losses.
- W is the weight. B is the ballast.
NCCI's worksheet shows the same math in a different order. It calls (1 − W) × Ee + B the stabilizing value and adds it to both sides.
A worked example
Uinta Roofing Co. is a fictional roofing subcontractor in an NCCI state. Its mod is effective January 1, 2026, so the experience period is its 2022, 2023 and 2024 policies. The rating values below are made up for illustration. Real ones depend on the state, the year and the company's size.
| Illustrative rating value | Amount |
|---|---|
| Expected losses (E) | $80,000 |
| Expected primary losses (Ep) | $32,000 |
| Expected excess losses (Ee) | $48,000 |
| Split point | $20,000 |
| Weight (W) | 0.10 |
| Ballast (B) | $30,000 |
| Medical-only claims | ERA applies, 30% counts |
Uinta had six claims in the experience period.
| Policy year | Claim | Type | Incurred | Primary used | Excess used |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2022 | Fall from ladder, broken wrist | Lost time | $45,000 | $20,000 | $25,000 |
| 2022 | Hand cut from flashing | Medical only | $3,000 | $900 | $0 |
| 2023 | Shoulder strain carrying bundles | Lost time | $16,000 | $16,000 | $0 |
| 2023 | Debris in eye | Medical only | $1,500 | $450 | $0 |
| 2024 | Back strain | Lost time | $12,500 | $12,500 | $0 |
| 2024 | Burn from torch | Medical only | $2,500 | $750 | $0 |
| Total | $80,500 | $50,600 | $25,000 | ||
- Split each claim. The $45,000 ladder fall puts $20,000 in primary and $25,000 in excess. Every other claim is under the split point, so it is all primary.
- Apply ERA to the medical-only claims. The $3,000 cut counts as $900, the $1,500 eye injury as $450 and the $2,500 burn as $750.
- Add up. Actual primary losses (Ap) are $50,600. Actual excess losses (Ae) are $25,000.
- Find the stabilizing value. $48,000 × (1 − 0.10) + $30,000 = $73,200.
- Weight the excess. Actual is 0.10 × $25,000 = $2,500. Expected is 0.10 × $48,000 = $4,800.
- Adjusted actual losses are $50,600 + $73,200 + $2,500 = $126,300.
- Adjusted expected losses are $32,000 + $73,200 + $4,800 = $110,000.
- The mod is $126,300 ÷ $110,000 = 1.148, shown as 1.15.
What the example shows
- Uinta's total losses ($80,500 before ERA) almost exactly match its expected losses ($80,000). It still gets a 1.15 debit because of frequency. Its actual primary losses of $50,600 are far above the $32,000 expected.
- Take out the $16,000 shoulder strain and the mod becomes $110,300 ÷ $110,000, or 1.00. One mid-size claim moved the mod 15 points.
- Without ERA, the medical-only claims count in full. Actual primary rises to $55,500 and the mod becomes 1.19.
- On $60,000 of premium before the mod, a 1.15 costs $9,000 more than a 1.00. The shoulder strain also stays in the 2025 and 2027 ratings.
Frequency versus severity
Granite Peak Builders is a fictional framing contractor. Its illustrative values are $100,000 of expected losses, $40,000 expected primary, a weight of 0.12, ballast of $35,000 and a $20,000 split point. Compare two versions of its record. Both have $60,000 of lost-time losses, well under the $100,000 expected.
| One large claim | Six small claims | |
|---|---|---|
| Claims | One $60,000 claim | Six $10,000 claims |
| Actual primary (Ap) | $20,000 | $60,000 |
| Actual excess (Ae) | $40,000 | $0 |
| Adjusted actual losses | $112,600 | $147,800 |
| Adjusted expected losses | $135,000 | $135,000 |
| Mod | 0.83 | 1.09 |
Same dollars, different mods. The company with six claims gets a debit. NCCI's guide makes the same point with ten small losses against one large loss of the same total.
EMR estimator
Enter numbers from your worksheet, or try what-ifs. The defaults are the Uinta example, so the weight and ballast are example values, not your state's. The estimator uses a simplified NCCI formula. It skips accident limits, ERA and state rules, so enter losses after any ERA reduction.
A 1.15 is a debit mod. It predicts future losses about 15% worse than the average employer in your classes. It would raise premium about 15%, or about $15,000 on $100,000 of premium before the mod.
Adjusted actual losses $126,300 ÷ adjusted expected losses $110,000.
This is an estimate, not a rating. Your official mod comes only from NCCI or your state rating bureau, using that year's state rating values.
What is a good EMR?
Lower is better. The plan is built around 1.0 as average, so anything under 1.0 means your losses ran better than expected for your size and trade.
There is no single industry cutoff. Each GC and owner sets its own. Some public owners publish theirs.
| Owner document | How it treats EMR |
|---|---|
| University of California, prequalification evaluation template | EMR must be less than 1.0 for each of the past three premium years. If not, the contractor is not prequalified. |
| Palomar Community College District, contractor prequalification application (2022 to 2023) | Scores the current mod. Under 1.0 earns 5 points. 1.0 to 1.5 earns 3. 1.51 to 2.0 earns 2. Over 2.0 earns 0. A three-year average under 1.0 earns 6 more points. |
| California Labor Commissioner, model prequalification questionnaire (March 2019) | Asks for the EMR for each of the past three premium years. Says the EMR should be stated in a letter from the carrier. Sets no EMR cutoff. |
How to read your own number as a sub:
- Under 1.0. You pass a 1.0 cutoff. Keep the carrier letter current.
- Exactly 1.00. Be ready to say whether it is calculated or a unity mod because you are not rated.
- Over 1.0. An owner with a hard 1.0 cutoff will screen you out. Others may ask why. Have a short letter ready that names the claims behind the mod and what you changed.
For GCs, read the mod with the company's size in mind. One claim can move a small sub's mod a lot, as the Uinta example shows. Ballast also limits how low a small company's mod can go. Look at the three-year trend and the claims behind it.
EMR versus TRIR and DART
Prequal forms often ask for all three. They measure different things.
| EMR | TRIR | DART rate | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it measures | Workers' comp claim dollars compared with expected | OSHA-recordable injuries and illnesses | Recordable cases with days away, restricted work or job transfer |
| Who calculates it | NCCI or the state bureau | The employer | The employer |
| Data | Payroll and claims reported by carriers | OSHA 300 log and hours worked | OSHA 300 log and hours worked |
| Period | About three policy years, ending a year before the rating date | Usually one calendar year | Usually one calendar year |
| Formula | Actual versus expected losses, with weight and ballast | Recordable cases × 200,000 ÷ hours worked | DART cases × 200,000 ÷ hours worked |
| Proof to ask for | Carrier letter and worksheet | OSHA 300A summary | OSHA 300A summary |
The 200,000 stands for 100 employees working 40 hours a week for 50 weeks. DART cases are columns H and I of the OSHA 300A summary. An injury is recordable if it leads to death, days away, restricted work or transfer, medical treatment beyond first aid, or loss of consciousness, among other criteria.
TRIR counts cases. EMR counts dollars. One expensive lost-time injury counts once in one year's TRIR, but it stays in the EMR for three ratings. Look at both. See the TRIR and DART calculator and the OSHA 300A guide.
How to lower your EMR
You can't change past claims. You can change the next three years and make sure the data is right. Start with how often people get hurt, since the formula weighs frequency most.
Prevent claims
- Put a written safety program for your trade in place and train crews on it. GCs ask for one in prequal too. Our free safety program builder writes one for your trade.
- Hold short, regular toolbox talks on the hazards of the current job.
- Pull your last three years of claims. Find the repeat causes, such as ladders, lifting, eye injuries or cuts, and fix those first.
Control the cost of the claims that happen
- Report every injury to your carrier right away. NCCI's guide notes that employer involvement can reduce the severity of losses once they occur.
- Set up a return-to-work program with light-duty tasks. Getting injured employees back to work as soon as reasonably possible is one of the incentives NCCI says experience rating is meant to create.
- Don't pay small claims out of pocket to keep them off your record. NCCI built ERA partly to reduce that incentive.
- Stay in touch with the adjuster on open claims. Ask for reserves to be reviewed as a claim nears closing.
Check the data
- Get your worksheet every year from your agent or carrier, and read it before the policy renews.
- Check that every claim is yours and sits in the right policy period.
- Check open claims. If one closed for less than its reserve, ask your agent whether a corrected report and a revised mod are possible.
- Check payroll by class code. Wrong class codes or payroll throw off expected losses.
- Report ownership changes to your carrier in writing within 90 days. NCCI uses its ERM-14 form for this.
Be patient. A clean year shows up in your mod about two years later, then stays for three ratings.
Need a written safety program for your next prequal?
Answer about a dozen questions and get a program written for your trade, citing the OSHA standard each section covers. Free.
How to read an EMR worksheet
NCCI's Experience Rating Worksheet has a summary page and one or more detail pages.
A note on "ERM-14"
The worksheet is sometimes called the ERM-14. That number belongs to a different NCCI form, the ERM-14 Request for Ownership Information. For prequal, what you want is the Experience Rating Worksheet and the carrier's mod letter.
The header
The top of each page shows the risk name, risk ID, state, rating effective date and production date. Also check the mod's status.
- Final. NCCI used the state's final approved rating values.
- Preliminary. NCCI used the prior values because the final ones weren't in yet. It will be revised.
- Contingent. NCCI was still waiting on audited payroll or loss data. It will be revised.
The detail page
There is one block per policy, with payroll on the left and claims on the right. The claims on a line are not tied to the class code on that line.
| Column | What it is | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Code | Class code | Matches the work your crews do |
| ELR, D-Ratio | Expected loss rate per $100 of payroll, and the share expected to be primary | Set by the rating organization |
| Payroll | Payroll for that class and policy | Matches your audited payroll |
| Expected Losses, Exp Prim Losses | ELR × payroll ÷ 100, then times the D-ratio | Follows from payroll |
| Claim Data | Claim number. Small claims may be grouped and shown as "NO." with a count. | Every claim is yours |
| IJ | Injury type. Type 6 is medical only. | Medical-only claims carry type 6, so ERA can apply |
| OF | O for open, F for final | Open claims with large reserves |
| Act Inc Losses | Actual incurred losses, indemnity plus medical | Values look current |
| Act Prim Losses | The part of each claim up to the split point | Large claims are capped here |
The detail page shows medical-only claims at full value. The ERA reduction shows up in the summary totals.
The summary page
| Box | Name | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| (A) | Wt | Weight from the state table |
| (C) | Exp Excess Losses | (D) minus (E) |
| (D) | Expected Losses | Total from the detail pages |
| (E) | Exp Prim Losses | Total from the detail pages |
| (F) | Act Exc Losses | (H) minus (I) |
| (G) | Ballast | From the state table |
| (H) | Act Inc Losses | Total actual losses used, after ERA |
| (I) | Act Prim Losses | Total actual primary losses used, after ERA |
| (J) | Actual total | (I) + stabilizing value + (A) × (F) |
| (K) | Expected total | (E) + stabilizing value + (A) × (C) |
| Exp Mod | The mod | (J) ÷ (K) |
The stabilizing value is (C) × (1 − (A)) + (G). The bottom row can also show assigned risk surcharge factors such as ARAP. Those mostly apply to assigned risk policies with a debit mod.
Before you send a worksheet to a GC, check that the risk name matches your legal entity, the rating effective date is current, and the states listed match where you work.
What GCs should ask for in prequalification
A number typed into a form is hard to check. Ask for documents.
- A mod letter covering three years. A letter on letterhead from the sub's carrier, agent or rating bureau, stating the mod and rating effective date for each of the last three years. California's model prequal questionnaire asks for three premium years and says the EMR should be stated in a carrier letter.
- The current worksheet. It shows the claims behind the number. Not every sub will share it. Ask anyway.
- Which states it covers. Interstate or intrastate. A sub working in Pennsylvania and an NCCI state has two mods.
- The status. A preliminary or contingent mod can change.
- An explanation for any 1.00. Calculated, or unity because the company is not rated? If not rated, ask for three years of carrier loss runs.
- An explanation for any mod over your cutoff. The claims behind it, what changed, and the trend.
- OSHA 300A summaries for the same three years. Use them for TRIR and DART. See the OSHA 300A guide.
- Proof of workers' comp coverage. See reading an ACORD 25 certificate, and the waiver of subrogation guide if your contract requires one.
- Self-insured or state fund proof where it applies. Some large companies are legally self-insured. In North Dakota, Ohio, Washington and Wyoming, the state fund handles experience rating.
Set your cutoff in writing before you send the form, and apply it to every sub the same way. Our free prequal form builder has a Safety section that asks for three years of EMR, the agent's letter and OSHA 300A summaries.
FAQ
What is a good EMR for a contractor?
Anything below 1.0 is better than average for your size and trade. There is no single industry cutoff. Some owners require an EMR below 1.0 for each of the last three years. Others score on a sliding scale. Ask each GC or owner what its cutoff is.
What does an EMR of 1.0 mean?
A 1.0 means your losses are in line with what the plan expects for your size and classes, so the mod does not raise or lower your premium. New businesses and employers that are not eligible for experience rating also carry 1.0.
How many years does an EMR cover?
Usually three years of payroll and losses, ending about a year before the rating effective date. A mod effective January 1, 2026 generally uses the policies that started in 2022, 2023 and 2024.
Who calculates my EMR?
NCCI calculates mods in most states. California, Delaware, Michigan, New Jersey and Pennsylvania have their own bureaus and plans. In Indiana, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New York, North Carolina and Wisconsin, the state bureau rates employers that work only in that state. North Dakota, Ohio, Washington and Wyoming use state funds.
Can I calculate my own EMR?
You can estimate it with the formula and estimator on this page, using the numbers on your worksheet. The official mod comes only from NCCI or your state bureau. They use state rating values that change every year.
How long does one claim affect my EMR?
A claim stays in the experience period for three ratings in a row. With January 1 renewals, a claim on a policy that started in 2023 is used in the mods effective in 2025, 2026 and 2027.
Does a medical-only claim hurt my EMR?
Less than a lost-time claim. In states that use NCCI's Experience Rating Adjustment, only 30% of a medical-only claim counts in the mod. It still counts, so report every injury to your carrier.
What is the difference between EMR and TRIR?
EMR is an insurance number built from three years of workers' comp claim dollars. TRIR is a rate of OSHA-recordable injuries and illnesses per 200,000 hours worked, usually for one year. GCs often ask for both.
Sources
- NCCI, ABCs of Experience Rating (copyright 1981 to 2021). The plan's purpose, frequency and severity, split rating, ERA, the experience period, eligibility, unity mods, the premium example and the worksheet layout.
- NCCI, Item E-1409, Enhancement to NCCI's Experience Rating Plan Methodology, as filed with the Texas Department of Insurance (2022). The $18,500 countrywide split point, state-specific split points, accident limits, weight and ballast, D-ratios, and the 1.20 example.
- Texas Commissioner of Insurance, Order No. 2023-7897 (April 20, 2023). Approval of Item E-1409 and the $16,500 Texas split point for ratings on or after July 1, 2024.
- California Department of Industrial Relations, Labor Commissioner's Model Pre-Qualification Questionnaire (March 2019).
- University of California Office of the President, Prequalification Evaluation template.
- Palomar Community College District, Contractor Pre-Qualification Application, 2022 to 2023.
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, How to compute nonfatal incidence rates.
- OSHA, 29 CFR 1904.7, General recording criteria.
- State rating bureaus, Indiana Compensation Rating Bureau and Minnesota Workers' Compensation Insurers Association.
We can make this easier
PreQualifySubs.com gives every GC one prequal link. Subs fill their profile once and reuse it for every GC. We check licenses, liens, OSHA records, insurance and references against the source, so you see a verified level instead of a stack of PDFs. Free for subs.