How to prequalify subcontractors
To prequalify subcontractors, (1) set pass/fail gates and scoring criteria, (2) send one form or link, (3) collect the 19 items, (4) verify each at the source, (5) score, (6) set tiers and award limits, and (7) monitor and renew. Gates such as an active license are pass or fail. Everything else is scored.
This guide explains common practice and cites the public record behind each check. Utah is the worked example for state records. It is not legal, insurance or financial advice. The scoring rubric is our example to adapt, not an industry standard.
What prequalification is, and isn't
Subcontractor prequalification is a review of a company before you let it bid or sign. It answers one question. Can this sub do this kind of work, at this size, safely, while paying its own crews and suppliers? You answer it from documents and public records. The result is a decision, a tier and a dollar limit.
| Step | The question it answers | When it happens |
|---|---|---|
| Prequalification | Is this company fit to bid on work like this, and up to what size? | Before bidding, then every year |
| License check | Does the state allow this company to do this trade? | Inside prequalification, and again before award |
| Bid leveling | Which bid is complete and the best value for this scope? | After bids come in |
| Onboarding | Is the paperwork in place to start this job? | After award, before the crew mobilizes |
A license check is one item inside prequalification. A license shows the state let the company in the door. It says nothing about whether the company can carry a $900,000 subcontract, or how often its crews get hurt.
Bid leveling compares bids for one scope. Prequalification decides whose bids you will take at all, so do it first. Onboarding comes after award and collects the paperwork for one project. See onboarding after award.
Who prequalifies whom
- GCs prequalify subs. That is the subject of this guide. AIA's A305-2020 Contractor's Qualification Statement is a standard form with five optional exhibits, and AIA notes that subs and suppliers can use it too. ConsensusDocs 721 is a subcontractor statement of qualifications. Both are paid forms. Our free prequal form covers the same ground, with your logo and the sections you pick.
- Owners prequalify GCs. Public owners often do it under a statute. California's Public Contract Code section 20101 lets public agencies require it. An agency that does must use a standardized questionnaire and financial statement, rate bidders on objective criteria, and offer an appeal. It may prequalify subs too.
- Subs prequalify their own sub-tiers. The method in this guide works one tier down.
When to prequalify
Prequalify on a schedule, per project when the risk calls for it, and whenever something changes.
Annually
Requalify every sub at least once a year. DPR, for example, requires every sub to be prequalified annually to bid with it. California's statute lets a public agency grant a prequalification that is good for one year.
Per project, for bigger or riskier scopes
Review again for a specific project when:
- the subcontract is larger than the sub's largest completed job, or above its award limit;
- the scope is high-hazard, such as roofing, steel erection, excavation or crane work;
- the owner's contract sets its own prequal rules or requires bonds;
- the job is in a state where the sub hasn't worked before.
On triggers
| Trigger | Why it matters | Re-check |
|---|---|---|
| A new claim or lien | The sub may not be paying its suppliers or sub-tiers. | Liens, judgments, financials, references |
| An OSHA citation | It shows a hazard the safety program missed. | OSHA inspections, safety program, 300A |
| A change of ownership or qualifier | You may be dealing with a different company. In Utah, a contractor whose qualifier leaves must tell DOPL within 10 days and replace the qualifier within 60 days, or the license is suspended. | Entity and principals, license and qualifier, EMR, W-9 |
| Slow payment to sub-tiers | Supplier calls and joint check requests often come before liens. | Liens, financials, references |
| A safety incident | A serious injury can bring an inspection now and a higher EMR later. | OSHA inspections, 300 log, safety program |
| An insurance lapse | A cancelled or expired policy leaves you exposed the same day. | Insurance, with the agent. Keep the crew off site until coverage is confirmed. |
Who is usually exempt
- Suppliers that only deliver. A supplier that also installs is a sub.
- Design consultants. Architects and engineers go through a professional services review built around their professional license and professional liability insurance.
- One-time services below a dollar line you set. Write the line down. Still collect a W-9 and a certificate of insurance.
The process, step by step
- Set criteria. Write your gates, weights and tier lines before you send anything, and use the same ones for every sub in a trade. California requires public agencies to rate bidders with a uniform system based on objective criteria. That is a good rule for private work too.
- Send one form or link. Ask for documents, not claims. A typed EMR is a claim. A carrier letter is a document. Our free prequal form builder makes a branded PDF with these sections.
- Collect documents. Use the 19 items below. Set a deadline, keep a list of what's missing, and chase it weekly.
- Verify at the source. Check each answer against the record that issued it, such as the licensing board, the court, the agent or the surety. See the verification playbook.
- Score. Run the pass/fail gates, then the weighted rubric. See how to score.
- Decide and set limits. Assign a tier, an award limit and any conditions. Record the reason and tell the sub.
- Monitor and renew. Track expiration dates, re-check on triggers, and requalify every year.
What to collect: the 19 items
These 19 items cover five risk areas. Ask for the exact document named. A vague request gets a vague answer.
Identity and licensing
| Item | Exactly what to ask for | Where to verify it | Red flags |
|---|---|---|---|
| Entity and principals | Legal name, DBAs, entity type, state and date formed, former names, affiliates. Every owner, officer and manager, with ownership percentage. | The state business entity search. In Utah, the Division of Corporations. | Status other than active. A legal name that differs from the W-9, license or certificate. Principals missing from the state record. A new company claiming a long history. |
| License and qualifier | Every contractor license, with state or city, number, classification and expiration. The qualifier's name and title. | The state license lookup. In Utah, DOPL. Utah requires a qualifier who is an owner, officer or manager with real authority over the contracting work. | A classification that doesn't cover your scope. Expired or suspended status. A license in another company's name. A qualifier who has left. |
| Disciplinary actions | Any suspension, revocation, probation or citation in the last 5 years against the company or its qualifier. | The licensing board. In Utah, DOPL's disciplinary search, under the company and the qualifier. | Discipline the sub didn't disclose. Citations for unlicensed work. |
| W-9 | IRS Form W-9 with the full legal name, signed and dated within the last 12 months. | Compare the name with the entity record. GCs that file 1099s can use IRS TIN Matching. | A name that doesn't match the company signing your subcontract. A TIN mismatch. An unsigned or old form. |
| Business certifications | Each certificate, with the certifying agency, number and expiration. DBE, MBE, WBE, SBE, 8(a), HUBZone, WOSB or veteran-owned. | The certifying agency's directory. In Utah, the Utah Unified Certification Program DBE directory. For SBA certifications, SBA's Small Business Search. | A firm missing from the directory. An expired certificate. A certificate held by an affiliate. A self-claimed status shown as a certification. |
DBE status is changing. A USDOT interim final rule published October 3, 2025 requires every Unified Certification Program to reevaluate the DBEs it certified and decertify those that don't meet the new standards. Check the directory on the day you rely on it.
Legal and records
| Item | Exactly what to ask for | Where to verify it | Red flags |
|---|---|---|---|
| Liens | Every lien or bond claim recorded in the last 5 years over money the company owed, and how each was resolved. | The county recorder in each county where the sub worked. Utah records liens with the county recorder. Its State Construction Registry holds the preliminary notices that come first. | Liens by the sub's own suppliers or sub-tiers. No recorded release. Federal tax liens. Liens on several jobs. |
| Judgments and lawsuits | Pending or unpaid suits, claims, arbitrations and judgments against the company or its officers. Construction suits it filed in 5 years. | State court records. In Utah, the courts' XChange system. Federal cases in PACER. | Unpaid judgments. Suppliers suing for payment. Suits after a termination. |
| Bankruptcy | Any bankruptcy or reorganization by the company or a principal in the last 7 years. | PACER, which covers the federal bankruptcy courts. | An open case. A principal whose last company failed. A filing the sub didn't disclose. |
| Federal debarment | Any suspension or debarment of the company or a principal by a federal or state agency. | SAM.gov exclusions, by company, principal and UEI. The state's list where one exists. | An active exclusion. An exclusion under a former name. |
| Environmental actions | Any environmental enforcement action or consent order in the last 5 years. | EPA ECHO's enforcement case search. The state environmental agency. | Open or repeat cases. Cases tied to job site stormwater, dust or waste. |
| Sworn disclosures | Yes or no answers, signed by an officer, on defaults, terminations for cause, unfinished work, surety claims, principals of failed companies and business crimes. An explanation for every yes. | Cross-check each answer against the records above. | A no that a public record contradicts. A signer who isn't an officer. |
California's model questionnaire is answered under oath, and intentionally false information is grounds for disqualification on its own. Put the same statement on your form.
Safety
| Item | Exactly what to ask for | Where to verify it | Red flags |
|---|---|---|---|
| OSHA inspections | Every federal or state OSHA citation in the last 5 years, with date, standard, penalty and resolution. | OSHA's establishment search, which includes state-plan inspections. | Willful or repeat violations. The same standard cited twice. A fatality inspection. Citations the sub didn't list. |
| Safety rating (EMR) | The EMR for each of the last 3 years, in a letter from the carrier, agent or rating bureau, with each rating effective date. | Call the agent and ask for the worksheet. See the EMR guide. | A mod over 1.0, or rising. A unity 1.00 because the company isn't rated. Numbers with no letter. |
| Safety program and OSHA 300A | The written safety program for the trade. OSHA 300A summaries for 3 years, with total hours worked. Training records, such as toolbox talk sign-in sheets. | Recompute TRIR and DART with the TRIR and DART calculator. Compare with the BLS rate for the sub's industry and year. | A blank hours box. A 300A no executive certified. A generic program. A company with more than 10 employees that keeps no OSHA records, since construction isn't partially exempt. |
The OSHA 300A guide covers who must keep the forms and how to read them.
Insurance and bonding
| Item | Exactly what to ask for | Where to verify it | Red flags |
|---|---|---|---|
| Insurance (COI) | A sample ACORD 25 with your required lines and limits. The agent's name, phone and email. Copies of the additional insured, waiver and primary and non-contributory endorsements. Insurer NAIC numbers. | Call the agent at a number you looked up. Check each insurer's AM Best rating. See how to read an ACORD 25. | The wrong named insured. Expired dates. An ADDL INSD or SUBR WVD mark with no endorsement. Claims-made liability when you require occurrence. A certificate sent by the sub, with signs of editing. |
| Surety and bonding | A letter on the surety's letterhead, dated within 30 days, showing single-project capacity, aggregate capacity and the amount available. Any surety claims in 5 years. | Call the surety's bond department, not only the agent. For federal work, check Treasury Circular 570. | An agent's letter with no surety confirmation. No dollar amounts. A surety that has paid a claim for the sub. |
DPR asks for a surety letter dated within 30 days. California's model asks for a notarized statement from the surety itself, not an agent or broker.
Financial and experience
| Item | Exactly what to ask for | Where to verify it | Red flags |
|---|---|---|---|
| Financial statements | CPA statements for the last fiscal year end, with the CPA's dated report, balance sheet and income statement. Internal statements for the latest month. A WIP schedule. An AR aging. A bank letter, dated within 30 days, showing the credit line and the amount drawn. | Call the CPA firm and the banker at numbers you found yourself. | Statements for a parent or holding company, not the contracting company. Internal statements only. Negative working capital. Old receivables. A fully drawn line. An auditor's going-concern doubt. |
| Project experience | Projects completed in 5 years, with scope, value, GC or owner, completion date and contact. Current backlog, with percent complete. | Call the contacts. Confirm each project exists through permit records or the owner. | No project near your size. Contacts you can't reach. Backlog that is large next to working capital. |
| References | At least two GCs, one supplier and one owner or architect, with a named contact and phone. | Call each with the reference script. | A supplier reporting slow pay. A GC that wouldn't hire them again. References who are relatives. |
Compiled, reviewed or audited
Read the CPA's report page. It names the kind of engagement, and that tells you how much the CPA checked.
| Level | What the CPA does | Assurance | Fair use in prequal |
|---|---|---|---|
| Internal | Nothing. The company prepares them. | None | Interim months only |
| Compiled | Presents management's numbers as financial statements. | None | Small subs on small scopes |
| Reviewed | Makes inquiries and runs analytical procedures. | Limited | Most mid-size subcontracts |
| Audited | Tests the records and gathers outside evidence. | High, but not absolute | Large or bonded scopes |
The assurance levels are the AICPA's. Owners draw the line in different places. California's model accepts only reviewed or audited statements. DPR accepts an audit, review or compilation.
- WIP schedule. One line per open job, with contract value, cost to date, cost to complete, billings and over or under billing. It shows backlog and whether jobs make money. DPR lets subs black out project names, GC names and cost and profit columns.
- AR aging. What customers owe, sorted by age. Old receivables may never be collected.
- Working capital and current ratio. Working capital is current assets minus current liabilities. The current ratio is current assets divided by current liabilities. The rubric uses the ratio. Award limits use working capital.
Put this on a prequal form you can send today
The free prequal form generator builds a branded subcontractor prequalification PDF. Add your logo, pick sections, download.
How to verify each answer at the source
A form records what the sub says. Verification checks it against the record that issued it. California's model questionnaire expects most answers to be taken at face value and lists public sources for checking them. We suggest checking every item. Most sources are free or cost a few dollars.
Utah state records
Other states keep the same records under names such as the Secretary of State, the licensing board and the county recorder.
| Record | Where | How to search it |
|---|---|---|
| Entity and principals | Utah Division of Corporations business entity search | Search by name. Compare the status, registered agent and the principals filed with the state against the form. |
| License, qualifier and discipline | Utah Division of Professional Licensing (DOPL), Licensee Lookup and Verification | Search by license number, then by company name with the "containing" option to catch other licenses. Check classification, status, expiration and qualifier. Run the disciplinary search for the company and the qualifier. |
| Preliminary notices | Utah State Construction Registry | Look up projects the sub worked on. Filings are indexed by owner, original contractor, project, parcel, address and county. Anyone who wants a lien must first file a preliminary notice here, usually within 20 days of starting work. |
| Liens | The county recorder in each county where the sub worked | Search for notices of construction lien, recorded releases and federal tax liens, under every name variant. |
| Lawsuits and judgments | Utah State Courts XChange | Search by party name. Pay as you go at $0.35 a search, or subscribe for $40 a month with 500 searches. Most district courts have public terminals. |
A lien is indexed under whatever name the claimant typed. For a fictional Uinta Roofing Co., search "Uinta Roofing Co", "Uinta Roofing Company", "Uinta Roofing LLC", "Uinta Roofing" alone, any DBA or former name, and misspellings such as "Unita". For a sole proprietor, search the owner too.
Federal records
| Record | Where | How to search it |
|---|---|---|
| OSHA inspections | OSHA establishment search | Enter the name with % wildcards, such as %uinta roof%. Include federal and state inspections and the last 5 years. Check the address on every hit, since OSHA warns that different companies may have similar names. Citations can change through settlement or contest. |
| Federal debarment | SAM.gov exclusions search | No account needed. Search the company, its UEI and each principal. A record names the agency, the cause and the end date. |
| Environmental actions | EPA ECHO | Run the enforcement case search with the company name, and the facility search for its shop or yard. |
| Federal suits and bankruptcy | PACER Case Locator | Search by party name across federal district, bankruptcy and appellate courts. You need an account. Pages cost $0.10, capped at $3 per document, and fees are waived if you spend $30 or less in a quarter. |
Third-party confirmations
- Insurance. Call the insurance agent listed on the certificate, at a number you found yourself. Confirm each policy is in force, with its limits and endorsements. Note who you spoke to and when.
- Insurer strength. Look up each insurer on AM Best, which needs a free member profile. Compare it with your written minimum, such as A- or A:VII.
- Surety. Call the surety's bond department to confirm the letter. For federal bonds, check that the surety is on Treasury Circular 570. Each listed company has an underwriting limitation, the most it can take on one bond. Under 31 CFR 223.10, that is 10 percent of its paid-up capital and surplus.
- EMR. Confirm the mod and its effective date with the agent or rating bureau.
- W-9. If you filed 1099s in the last 2 years, enroll in IRS TIN Matching and check the name and taxpayer ID before you pay.
Reference checks with a 6-question script
Call the reference's main number and ask for the person named. Ask the same six questions every time and write down the answers. The script is ours, drawing on the reference interview in California's model questionnaire.
- What did they do for you, when, and for about how much?
- Did they staff the job with enough people and supervision, and hold the schedule?
- How was the quality of the work and the closeout, including punch list and warranty calls?
- Did they pay their own suppliers and sub-tiers on time? Were there liens, joint checks or claims?
- How did they handle change orders and paperwork?
- Would you hire them again for a job this size? If not, why not?
Identity, the anti-fraud step
A form can carry a real company's name and license number with someone else's phone number and bank details. Two checks close that gap.
- Call a number you found yourself. Use the phone number listed on a public business record, or on the company's own website reached by search. Never use the number the sub wrote on the form. Some records leave phones out, and DOPL doesn't include them in the licensee lists it releases. Ask for the person who submitted the prequal and confirm they sent it.
- Confirm the signer is a listed principal. The person who signed up should appear on the state entity record or as the license qualifier. If not, get written authority from someone who does.
Do the same for bank details. The FBI tells businesses to verify payment changes in person or through a known telephone number.
Start with the free prequal form. PreQualifySubs.com can then run these checks on every answer automatically.
How to score subcontractors
Score in two stages. Gates come first, and they are pass or fail. Then a weighted rubric scores each risk area from 1 to 5 against written anchors. Public owners use the same shape. California's model disqualifies a contractor on essential questions, then scores the rest. The University of California's template mixes pass/fail items with points.
Pass/fail gates
| Gate | Passes when | Checked at |
|---|---|---|
| Active entity | The state record shows the entity active, not expired, delinquent or dissolved. | State entity search |
| License for the trade | Where the state requires one, the license is active, the classification covers the scope and a qualifier is in place. | State license lookup |
| No debarment or suspension | Neither the company nor a principal has an active federal exclusion or state suspension. | SAM.gov and state lists |
| Required insurance in force | Every line you require exists and is current for the work dates. | The agent |
| Endorsements available | The agent confirms in writing that the sub will provide the endorsements you require. | The agent |
| Identity confirmed | A call to an independently found number reached the company, and the submitter is a listed principal or authorized by one. | Public records and a call |
A sub that fails a gate isn't scored. Tell it which gate failed and what would fix it.
The weighted rubric, an example to adjust
Identity and licensing is handled by the gates, so it carries no weight. Change the weights to fit your work. A GC doing occupied hospital work might weight safety higher. Write them down before you score anyone, and use the same ones for every sub in a category.
| Area | Example weight | Scored on |
|---|---|---|
| Safety | 30% | Three years of EMR, adjusted for TRIR and the written program |
| Financial and experience | 35% | Current ratio and comparable projects, averaged |
| Insurance and bonding | 20% | Limits and endorsements |
| Legal and records | 15% | Liens, suits and judgments over three years |
Safety
Score the average of the last three years' EMR.
| Three-year EMR | Score |
|---|---|
| 0.80 or lower | 5 |
| 0.81 to 0.90 | 4 |
| 0.91 to 1.00 | 3 |
| 1.01 to 1.20 | 2 |
| Over 1.20 | 1 |
- Lower it one level if the sub's TRIR is above the BLS rate for its industry in the same year.
- Cap it at 3 if the sub has no written safety program.
- A unity 1.00 for an unrated company scores 3 by the table. Read its loss runs before you accept that.
Financial and experience
This area is the average of two parts.
| Current ratio | Score | Comparable projects in 5 years | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.0 or higher | 5 | 5 or more | 5 |
| 1.5 to 1.99 | 4 | 3 to 4 | 4 |
| 1.2 to 1.49 | 3 | 2 | 3 |
| 1.0 to 1.19 | 2 | 1 | 2 |
| Under 1.0 | 1 | None | 1 |
- Cap the current ratio part at 3 if the statements are internal only.
- Two bad references drop the projects part one level.
- Define "comparable" first. One workable definition is the same scope at half or more of the subcontract value you're buying.
Insurance and bonding
| Finding | Score |
|---|---|
| Meets every limit and endorsement | 5 |
| Meets limits, with endorsements to follow on the project certificate | 4 |
| A minor gap that can be fixed before award | 3 |
| Below your limits | 1 |
No bonding, where the work requires bonds, means the sub isn't eligible for bonded scopes.
Legal and records
| Last 3 years | Score |
|---|---|
| Clean | 5 |
| Resolved items, explained, such as a released lien or a closed suit | 4 |
| One open item with a plan | 3 |
| Several open items | 2 |
| A pattern of unpaid liens or judgments | 1 |
From score to tier
The weighted score is 0.30 × Safety + 0.35 × Financial and experience + 0.20 × Insurance and bonding + 0.15 × Legal and records.
| Weighted score | Tier | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| 4.0 or more | Tier 1 | Approved up to the award limit. |
| 3.0 to 3.99 | Tier 2 | Approved with conditions, such as a lower limit, a bond, joint checks or closer monitoring. |
| Under 3.0 | Not approved for now | Tell the sub what would change the result. |
A worked example with Uinta Roofing Co.
Uinta Roofing Co. is a fictional roofing sub that passed all six gates. Granite Peak Builders, also fictional, is considering it for an unbonded reroof. These numbers are invented for this example and differ from the Uinta figures in our EMR and TRIR guides.
| Area | Evidence | Score | Weight | Weighted |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Safety | Three-year EMR of 0.86. TRIR at or below the BLS rate for roofing contractors. Written program on file. | 4 | 0.30 | 1.200 |
| Financial and experience | Current ratio of 1.6 scores 4. Five comparable projects score 5. The average is 4.5. | 4.5 | 0.35 | 1.575 |
| Insurance and bonding | Meets every limit, with additional insured to be shown on the project certificate. No bonding, so not eligible for bonded scopes. | 4 | 0.20 | 0.800 |
| Legal and records | One lien in three years, released, with the release recorded. | 4 | 0.15 | 0.600 |
| Total | 0.30 × 4 + 0.35 × 4.5 + 0.20 × 4 + 0.15 × 4 | 1.00 | 4.175 |
A weighted score of 4.175 puts Uinta in Tier 1 for unbonded work. It isn't eligible for bonded scopes until it has a surety. Its award limit comes from the next section.
Blank scoring worksheet
Copy this table into your own file, or print the page.
| Line | Evidence and source checked | Result or score | Weight | Weighted |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sub and trade | ||||
| Active entity (gate) | Pass / Fail | |||
| License for the trade (gate) | Pass / Fail | |||
| No debarment or suspension (gate) | Pass / Fail | |||
| Required insurance in force (gate) | Pass / Fail | |||
| Endorsements available (gate) | Pass / Fail | |||
| Identity confirmed (gate) | Pass / Fail | |||
| Safety | 0.30 | |||
| Financial and experience | 0.35 | |||
| Insurance and bonding | 0.20 | |||
| Legal and records | 0.15 | |||
| Weighted total | 1.00 | |||
| Tier and bonded eligibility | ||||
| Award limit and conditions | ||||
| Reviewer, date and next review |
Tiers and award limits
The tier says whether a sub can work for you. The award limit says how much. Set both and write them in the file.
Bonded subs
For a bonded scope, the surety letter sets the ceiling. Use the single-project capacity as the most you award on one job, and check the amount available against the aggregate. Subcontract bonds are usually written for 100% of the subcontract amount. A bond is also a form of prequalification, because the surety has already underwritten the sub's finances, experience and current work.
Unbonded subs
No surety has done that review, so you size the limit yourself. Start from working capital. It is the cushion that carries payroll and materials until you pay.
Sureties size bonding programs from working capital, net worth, experience and backlog. A practice manual published by the State Bar of Arizona says some sureties won't let a contractor carry uncompleted work of more than 10 times its analyzed working capital, and that newer, smaller contractors should carry less. Sureties adjust the book numbers first, and each sets its own multiple.
A conservative starting cap, based on that rule of thumb, treats 10 times working capital as the ceiling on all of the sub's uncompleted work, including yours. Your award limit is that ceiling minus the uncompleted work already on its WIP schedule. Start lower for a newer or smaller sub. This is our suggestion, not a surety standard.
| Uinta Roofing Co. (fictional) | Amount |
|---|---|
| Current assets | $1,120,000 |
| Current liabilities | $700,000 |
| Working capital (current ratio 1.6) | $420,000 |
| Ceiling on uncompleted work, 10 × working capital | $4,200,000 |
| Uncompleted work on its WIP schedule | $2,900,000 |
| Starting award limit | $1,300,000 |
A $640,000 reroof fits. A $1.6 million job doesn't, unless Uinta gets bonded or its backlog drops.
Single-project and aggregate exposure
- Single-project exposure is your largest open subcontract with the sub, the most you lose if it fails on one job.
- Aggregate exposure is all your open subcontracts with that sub. Three jobs at once is three times the exposure. Set an aggregate limit too.
- Backlog comes from the WIP schedule. Compare it with working capital at every review. Backlog that rises while working capital stays flat is a warning.
Some large GCs buy subcontractor default insurance instead of requiring sub bonds. The GC then does the prequalification itself and shares losses through a deductible and co-pay, so these steps matter more, not less.
Insurance requirements to set
Set your requirements once, put them in the subcontract, and use the same ones on the prequal form. The short version:
- Lines and limits. General liability, business auto, umbrella or excess, and workers' comp with employer's liability. Our form builder starts at $1,000,000 each occurrence and $2,000,000 aggregate for general liability, $1,000,000 for auto, $5,000,000 umbrella, and statutory comp with $1,000,000 employer's liability. Change them to match your owner contracts.
- Additional insured for ongoing and completed operations, through CG 20 10 and CG 20 37 or forms as broad. See the additional insured guide.
- Waiver of subrogation on general liability, auto and comp, through endorsements such as CG 24 04 and WC 00 03 13. A few states restrict comp waivers. See the waiver of subrogation guide.
- Primary and non-contributory wording, through CG 20 01 or an equivalent. See the primary and non-contributory guide.
- Insurer strength. A minimum AM Best rating, such as A- or A:VII.
- The certificate. An ACORD 25 is evidence that policies existed, not coverage. See how to read an ACORD 25.
After award: prequalification versus onboarding
Prequalification decides who may bid, and up to what size. Onboarding happens after award, before the crew shows up. A prequalified sub can still be unready to start.
- An executed subcontract, signed before work starts, with your insurance requirements and the owner contract terms that flow down. Waiver and additional insured endorsements often depend on a written contract.
- The project certificate, naming your company and the project, with the required endorsements attached. See the additional insured, waiver and primary and non-contributory guides.
- The site-specific safety plan and orientation. The plan applies the sub's written program to this job's hazards. The requirement usually comes from the GC or owner, not OSHA. See site-specific safety plans. Orient each worker before they start, and keep weekly toolbox talks going.
- Submittals, such as product data, shop drawings and samples, on the subcontract schedule.
- A lien waiver process. A conditional waiver with each pay application, a final waiver at final payment, and waivers from the sub's own suppliers. Utah's statute sets out a conditional progress waiver form and a final payment waiver form.
- Certified payroll on public work, if it applies. The Davis-Bacon Act covers federal and federally assisted construction contracts over $2,000. On those jobs, contractors and subcontractors submit payroll every week. DOL's Form WH-347 is optional, but the weekly payroll and signed statement of compliance are not. State prevailing wage laws can add rules.
- Billing setup, including the pay application format, schedule of values, retention, and any joint check agreement for a Tier 2 sub.
Renewals and monitoring
A prequalification is a snapshot. Keep four rhythms.
| Check | How often | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Annual renewal | Every 12 months | Send the form or link again. Re-verify the public records and re-score. |
| Certificate expiration dates | All year | Log every policy's expiration date and get the renewal certificate before it passes. No current coverage, no site access. |
| Trigger re-checks | When a trigger happens | Re-check the items listed under triggers. |
| Active-project re-checks | Every 30 days while the sub is on your job | Re-run the license, SAM.gov, OSHA, lien and court searches. |
Rate performance after every project
The best evidence about a sub is how it worked for you. Have the PM and superintendent score it at closeout. This scorecard is our example.
| Category | A 5 looks like | A 1 looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Safety | No recordables, clean site audits | A recordable or citation tied to unsafe practice |
| Schedule | Met every milestone, staffed to plan | Delayed other trades or the finish |
| Quality | Short punch list, no rework | Rework or warranty failures |
| Paperwork | Submittals, pay apps, waivers and closeout on time | Missing documents held up payment |
| Payment to sub-tiers | No supplier calls, no liens | Liens or joint check demands |
| Cooperation | Solved problems with other trades | Disputes management had to settle |
File it with the sub's prequal record and read it at the next requalification. An average under 3, or any 1, should prompt a closer look before the next award.
Do you need prequalification software?
Not to start. A spreadsheet can hold one row per sub, with trade, tier, award limit, review date, policy expiration dates and a link to its documents. It breaks in four places.
- Expirations. A spreadsheet doesn't warn you. An expired policy looks the same as a current one.
- Chasing documents. Requests, reminders and versions scatter across email.
- Verification. It stores what the sub told you. It checks none of it.
- An audit trail. It doesn't record who changed a tier, when, or on what evidence.
How to judge any tool
| Question | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Does it verify at the source, or only collect uploads? | A folder of uploaded PDFs is still unverified. |
| Who pays? | Some platforms charge subs. Small subs may decline, and your bid list shrinks. |
| Can a sub reuse one profile across GCs? | Subs who keep one profile answer faster and keep it current. |
| Who owns the data, and can you export it? | You need your records if you switch. |
| Does it keep an audit trail of decisions? | Each decision should show its evidence and who made it. |
| How does it handle disputes? | Subs need a way to see a record and get errors fixed. |
PreQualifySubs.com is free for subs and verifies each item at the source.
Fairness, disputes and the law
A prequal decision can cost a sub work. Run it so you could defend it.
- Apply the same criteria to everyone. Same form, gates and weights for every sub in a category. California's uniform rating requirement binds only public agencies, but it is a sound model.
- Document every decision. Keep the worksheet, the sources checked, the dates and who decided.
- Let subs see and correct records. Show the sub the record you relied on. Public records have errors, and OSHA warns that different companies may have similar names.
- Run an appeal path. California requires a public agency to tell a denied bidder the basis in writing, share the evidence, and let the bidder rebut it. Do the same, with a deadline.
- Keep financials confidential. In California, public agencies' prequal questionnaires and financial statements are not public records, though applicants' names are. Treat yours the same way, and sign an NDA if a sub asks.
- Keep records only as long as you need them. The FTC's guide for businesses says to keep sensitive personal information only as long as you need it, then dispose of it properly. Set a retention period.
Credit reports on individual owners
Reports about companies generally fall outside the Fair Credit Reporting Act. FTC staff wrote in 2011 that reports about corporations and other entities are not consumer reports. A credit bureau's report on a person's own credit is a consumer report, even when you use it for a business decision.
So if you pull reports on a sub's owners, you need a permissible purpose. FTC staff read the business-transaction purpose as covering personal, family or household transactions, not purely commercial ones. For business credit, staff said a report on an individual is allowed only when that person will be personally liable, such as a guarantor. In one example, staff said a state had no permissible purpose to pull reports on the officers of companies bidding for a procurement contract.
Staff also read "employment purposes" to reach some people who aren't employees, such as owner-operator truck drivers. That use brings disclosure and written-consent rules. If you take adverse action based on a consumer report, the Act requires a notice. If you keep consumer report information, the FTC's Disposal Rule requires you to dispose of it properly.
The FTC report is staff guidance, and interpretive authority under the Act has since moved to the CFPB. Talk to counsel before you pull a consumer report on any individual. This section is not legal advice.
Prequalifying with a small team
A three-person GC can't run a full review on every sub. It can run the checks that catch the worst problems. Collect a W-9, the license number, a sample certificate with the agent's contact, the EMR letter, three years of 300A summaries with hours, a CPA statement or bank letter, three references and the signed disclosure page. Then run these checks.
| Check | Minutes |
|---|---|
| State entity search, principals against the form | 5 |
| License, qualifier and discipline lookup | 5 |
| SAM.gov exclusions, company and principals | 3 |
| OSHA establishment search | 5 |
| County recorder and state court searches | 15 |
| Call the insurance agent | 10 |
| Two reference calls with the script | 15 |
| Identity call to an independently found number | 5 |
| Total | 63 |
The minutes are our estimate for a sub with a complete package and a short history. Score with the gates and the rubric. Set a dollar line above which you also read the full financial package.
For subcontractors: how to pass prequalification faster
GCs ask for the same documents again and again. Keep a ready package in one folder, current, and you can answer most prequals in a day.
- A W-9 signed within the last 12 months, in your exact legal name
- Every license, with the qualifier's name
- A sample ACORD 25, your endorsements and your agent's contact details
- An EMR letter covering three years
- Three years of OSHA 300A summaries with total hours worked
- Your written safety program and recent toolbox talk sign-in sheets
- CPA statements, a WIP schedule, an AR aging and a bank line letter
- A surety letter, refreshed every 30 days if you bid bonded work
- A five-year project list, and references who expect a call
Make your legal name match on the W-9, license, certificate and state record. Explain every yes on the disclosure page. Tell your agent, surety and banker that GCs may call. If you need a written safety program, the free OSHA safety program template builds one for your trade in about 10 minutes. Our guide to writing a construction safety program covers what reviewers check.
FAQ
How long does subcontractor prequalification take?
Most of the time goes to waiting for documents. Once a sub sends a complete package, the lean review in this guide takes about an hour, by our estimate. A full financial review for a large scope takes longer. Reuse what you verified last year and re-check what changed.
How often should you requalify a subcontractor?
At least once a year, and again for any project above the sub's award limit. Re-check right away after a new lien or claim, an OSHA citation, a serious incident, an insurance lapse, or a change of owner or qualifier. Track certificate expiration dates all year.
What EMR is acceptable for a subcontractor?
There is no single industry cutoff. Below 1.0 is better than average for the sub's size and trade. Some public owners require below 1.0 for each of the last three years. Our example rubric gives full marks at 0.80 or lower. One claim can move a small sub's mod a lot, so read the claims behind it.
Do small subcontractors need to be prequalified?
Yes, with a lighter review. A small sub can cause an injury or a lien as easily as a large one. Check the entity, license, insurance, OSHA record, SAM.gov, liens and two references. A company with 10 or fewer employees all last year may not have to keep OSHA injury records, so ask for hours worked instead.
Is a certificate of insurance proof of coverage?
No. The ACORD 25 says it is for information only and gives the holder no rights. It shows the policies existed when it was issued. Call the agent to confirm coverage is in force, and ask for the endorsements behind any additional insured or waiver marks.
What if a sub won't share its financial statements?
Offer alternatives. You can accept a CPA letter stating working capital and net worth, sign an NDA, or take CPA-prepared tax returns with an internal balance sheet. A bank reference letter shows the credit line. A payment and performance bond puts a surety's review behind the sub. If none works, lower the award limit or use joint checks.
Do you need software to prequalify subcontractors?
Not to start. A form, a spreadsheet and the free public records in this guide work for a short sub list. Software helps once you track many expiration dates and need an audit trail. Judge any tool by whether it verifies at the source, who pays, and whether you can export your data.
What is the difference between prequalification and a license check?
A license check confirms the state allows the company to do a trade. Prequalification includes that check and adds safety, insurance, bonding, finances, legal records, experience and references. A licensed sub can still fail prequalification.
Who prequalifies general contractors?
Owners do. Public owners often follow a statute. In California, a public agency that prequalifies bidders must use a standardized questionnaire, rate bidders on objective criteria and offer an appeal. Private owners set their own rules.
Sources
Checked November 15, 2026. Rules and fees change, so confirm a detail at the source before you rely on it.
Prequalification forms and public owner examples
- California Department of Industrial Relations, Labor Commissioner's Model Pre-Qualification Questionnaire (March 2019). Public Contract Code 20101, essential criteria, scoring, appeals, confidentiality, reference questions and verification sources.
- University of California Office of the President, Prequalification Evaluation template.
- DPR Construction, Subcontractor Prequalification. Annual prequalification, W-9 within the past year, surety and bank letters within 30 days, statements, WIP schedule, AR aging, and the NDA and tax return alternatives.
- AIA Contract Documents, Summary of A305-2020, and ConsensusDocs, 721 Statement of Qualifications.
Utah records and law
- Utah Division of Professional Licensing, Licensee Lookup and Verification, and its licensee list notes on leaving phone numbers out.
- Utah Code 58-55-304, contractor qualifiers, in force through December 31, 2026. H.B. 40 (2026) moves the same 10-day and 60-day rules to section 58-55-107 on January 1, 2027.
- Utah Division of Corporations, business entity search.
- Utah State Construction Registry, scr.utah.gov. Utah Code 38-1a-201 (the registry index), 38-1a-501 (preliminary notice), 38-1a-502 (liens recorded with the county recorder), 38-1a-802 (lien waiver forms) and Title 38, Chapter 6 (federal liens).
- Utah State Courts, XChange and XChange fees.
- Utah Department of Transportation, Civil Rights, home of the Utah Unified Certification Program DBE directory.
Federal records
- OSHA, Establishment Search, and 29 CFR 1904.1 and 1904.2 on recordkeeping exemptions.
- GSA, SAM.gov, and FAR 9.404 on exclusion records.
- EPA, Enforcement and Compliance History Online (ECHO).
- U.S. Courts, PACER pricing and PACER Case Locator.
- U.S. Department of Transportation, DBE program interim final rule (Federal Register, October 3, 2025).
- SBA, Small Business Search.
- IRS, TIN Matching.
- FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center, business email compromise PSA (April 6, 2020).
- Bureau of Labor Statistics, Table 1, incidence rates by industry, 2024.
- U.S. Department of Labor, Davis-Bacon and Related Acts and Form WH-347.
Insurance, surety and finance
- Bureau of the Fiscal Service, Treasury Circular 570, and 31 CFR 223.10.
- AM Best, ratings search and Guide to Best's Financial Strength Ratings.
- ACORD, ACORD 25 (2025/12), as posted by the New York Department of Financial Services.
- Steve Nelson, SureTec Insurance Company, Managing the Risk of Subcontractor Defaults (2007), hosted by NASBP. Subcontract bonds, bonding as prequalification, default insurance and holding company statements.
- State Bar of Arizona, Arizona Construction Law Practice Manual, 3rd ed. (2016), section 1.3.4, via vLex.
- AICPA & CIMA, compilation, review and audit, and Journal of Accountancy, SSARS No. 21 (October 2014).
Consumer reports and records
- FTC, 40 Years of Experience with the Fair Credit Reporting Act (July 2011), sections 603(d), 603(h), 604(a)(3) and 615(a).
- FTC, Disposing of Consumer Report Information? Rule Tells How, and Protecting Personal Information, a guide for business.
We can make this easier
PreQualifySubs.com gives every GC one prequal link. Subs fill their profile once and reuse it for every GC. We check licenses, liens, OSHA records, insurance and references against the source, so you see a verified level instead of a stack of PDFs. Free for subs.